The Paradox of “Stiffness” in Hypermobility: Why You Feel Tight (And Why Stretching Isn’t Working)
We all face physical challenges at some point in our lives, but those with hypermobile joints encounter a particularly confusing reality. Whether due to a specific condition or simply being naturally 'bendy' , you may possess the extreme range of motion required for participation in dance, gymnastics, yoga or simply entertaining your friends with your double-jointedness, yet simultaneously feel constantly tight and restricted. You might stretch for hours, to release that sensation of "tightness" in your hips or hamstrings. But the relief is usually temporary, and the stiffness often returns with a vengeance the next day.
This is the Hypermobile Person’s Paradox: possessing excessive flexibility, yet battling chronic, unremitting tension. The good news is that it isn’t in your head, and a lack of stretching isn't the problem. We now understand that this sensation is rarely due to true tissue shortening. Instead, it is a complex "protective tension”. In other words, it is your central nervous system trying to save you from yourself.
This blog will cover the following topics on the Hypermobile Paradox:
- Why Hypermobile People Feel Tight
- The "Sensorimotor Blur" – Proprioception & Hypermobility
- The Hip: The Epicentre of the Struggle for Pelvic Control
- What Can We Do about Paradoxical Stiffness in Hypermobility?
- Final thoughts
Find our physio clinic in Salisbury, Brisbane
Our Brisbane Physiotherapy Clinic, services areas including: Salisbury, Brisbane, Tarragindi, Mount Gravatt, Holland Park, Rocklea, Yeronga, Annerley, Camp Hill, Carindale, Coorparoo, Salisbury, Sunnybank, Greenslopes, Seven Hills, Acacia Ridge, Indooroopilly, Woolloongabba, etc.
Because of our expertise in hip conditions, hypermobility, sports injuries, and dance injuries and performance, we also have people visiting us from all over Queensland, Australia and even international visitors. We also have a telehealth service for remote patients.
The "Emergency Brake": Why Hypermobile People Feel Tight
To understand why you feel stiff, we must look at what is happening inside the joint capsule. In a stable joint, ligaments act as a passive "seatbelt." When you reach the end of your range, these ligaments pull taut to control the amount of sliding of the bones on one another. In hypermobile people, however, these passive structures are more elastic and then bones may naturally slide a little further than normal within a joint. This may sometimes be associated with pain and/or a feeling of instability – giving way or a heaviness in the limb.
Luckily though, your brain and central nervous system will do just about anything to prevent excessive joint gliding or subluxation and will reflexively engage an "Emergency Brake.” This is the recruitment of your strongest muscles, the global mobilizer muscles, like the hamstrings, quadriceps, and upper trapezius, to clamp down and effectively splint their respective joints.
This is the key. You perceive this protective guarding as “tightness,” and so naturally your instinct is to stretch it. But when you stretch a guarding muscle, you are fighting against this innate protective mechanism. Once you release the stretch, your nervous system senses the need to stabilize the mobile joint again and slams the brake on even harder.
Hypermobile individuals are often told they just need to stretch more. But if you’re constantly feeling tight despite having incredible flexibility, the issue may not be short muscles — it may be a nervous system working overtime to protect unstable joints.
If you’re stuck in the cycle of stretching, temporary relief, and recurring stiffness, it may be time to shift the focus from flexibility to stability.
Unsure whether your tightness is true restriction, protective guarding, neural tension, or joint instability?
Book in with one of our PhysioTec physiotherapists for a comprehensive hypermobility assessment. We’ll help you understand what your body is actually asking for, and build a personalised plan that supports your strength, control and long-term recovery.
The "Sensorimotor Blur" – Proprioception & Hypermobility
There is another layer to this paradox called Proprioception. Proprioception is your body’s ability to sense where your limbs are in space and to know how bent or straight a joint is without looking. This system relies on sensors, called mechanoreceptors, which are activated by tension. The trouble is that because these receptors exist within ligaments, and hypermobile ligaments are so stretchy, these receptors don’t fire off until the joint has already moved past a typical range of motion. This means the sensors don’t fire in time to give the nervous system a clear sense of what that joint is getting up to.
To compensate for this lack of clarity, your nervous system increases muscle tone, artificially creating sensory noise to allow it to track the limb. Essentially, this tightness is your body "shouting" at your brain to tell it where it is.
The Hip: The Epicentre of the Struggle for Pelvic Control
The pelvis is a huge body segment situated in the middle of the body. It’s responsible for transferring forces from gravity down to the feet and from the ground up towards the head. Control of the pelvis is central to efficient postures and dynamic movement.
A lack of pelvic control has been linked to many pain states and injuries. Many people with hypermobility experience feelings of tightness in the muscles around the hip and pelvis, a reflection of the nervous system’s attempt to control the transfer of forces through this area.
1. The "Tight" Hip Flexors (Iliopsoas):
Almost every hypermobile person experiences a feeling of tightness in their hip flexors at some point. But in many cases, this is not a short muscle. The iliopsoas is an important hip and pelvic stabilizer. In a hypermobile hip with reduced ligamentous stability, the ball of the hip joint might slide a little further forward than normal against the joint capsule, setting off warnings to engage the hip flexor ‘seatbelt’.
Your iliopsoas acts to support the mobile ligaments - a "dynamic ligament” so to speak. It contracts to support the femoral head in the socket. It also plays an important role in controlling pelvic tilt and lumbar spine (lower back) positioning.
If your iliopsoas is not up to the task alone, your nervous system often calls for help from your secondary hip flexors like your sartorius, tensor fascia lata (TFL), rectus femoris (part of your quadriceps in the front of the thigh) and sometimes even the inner thigh (adductor) muscles. Global upregulation (excessive gripping) of all these superficial muscles is usually the reason for feeling that sensation of constant tightness around the front and inner aspect of the hip and thigh.
Superficial hip flexor muscles have poor ability to provide local joint stability, whereas the iliopsoas is our most effective stabilizer. Unfortunately, this muscle is often demonized and tortured in various ways, but iliopsoas is your friend.
2. The "Locked" Hamstring:
Similarly, you may feel hamstring tightness, despite the muscle being long enough to allow you to move through large ranges when bending forward or even doing the splits.
In some hypermobile people, the hamstrings do become shortened due to certain standing postures and movement habits, where the pelvis shifts forward and the hips are in more than typical hip extension. This puts the hamstrings into a relatively shortened position and may over time result in adaptive shortening.
Others, particularly those involved in performance sports like dance and gymnastics, may have trained to lock into a forward pelvic tilt. This is a phenomenon of being "locked long" – with the hamstrings in a lengthened position. This alignment positions your sit bones (ischial tuberosities) high and back, tensioning the hamstrings like an archer drawing back a bow. The muscles are structurally long, but because the slack has been pulled out of them by your posture, they feel short.
‘Locked’ hamstrings can also just be another compensatory strategy for trying to achieve control of hypermobile knees and hips, and to try to assist in controlling the pelvis from below. This is terribly inefficient and much better achieved with the shorter muscles around the hip.
However, if the shorter hip muscles are not providing adequate support, the nervous system will ask for additional help from the thigh muscles, including the long superficial hip flexors at the front, the hamstrings at the back, and the adductor muscles of the inner thigh. All this extra muscle usage can leave you feeling not just tight, but quite exhausted!
3. The "Tethered" Sciatic Nerve:
Finally, what feels like hamstring stiffness can sometimes be ‘neural tension’ – a feeling of tension from a nerve. The sciatic nerve runs from the lower back down through the buttock and back of the thigh. Excess muscle tension around the back, hip and thigh may reduce the nerve’s ability to smoothly glide through these areas as you move.
If what you are feeling is actually neural tension, rather than muscle tension, static stretching will usually be fairly ineffective. In some situations, stretching may aggravate nerve related pain, which in turn may increase protective muscle tension around the nerve.
Feeling constantly “tight” despite your flexibility?
Struggling with hips or hamstrings that never seem to release, no matter how much you stretch?
Let one of our experienced PhysioTec physiotherapists assess your movement, identify what’s driving your tension, and create a personalised plan to help calm protective guarding and improve stability.
Helping you move with confidence and get you moving at your best.
So, What Can We Do about Paradoxical Stiffness in Hypermobility?
We need to shift the goal from Flexibility to Stability. We need to convince your nervous system that the joint is safe so that it can release the emergency brake.
1. Stop the "Comfort" Stretching
It requires a massive shift in mindset to stop stretching, but for the hypermobile person, aggressive static stretching is often not a great idea. While you may feel temporary relief from that feeling of tightness, it may leave your joints temporarily less supported, especially if your deep stabilizers are not doing their job well. You may also aggravate joint pain by sustaining a joint in its end-range position.
Try a hot pack, relaxed breathing, and progressive muscle relaxation – gently contracting and relaxing your muscles from head to toe, or in the area of greatest tension. This will help with temporary relief of symptoms, while you work on the other active strategies below that aim to improve the situation in the longer term.
2. The "Active Seatbelt"
We need to optimize function of your deep, local stabilizing muscles to provide additional support for your more flexible ligaments and joints. If these muscles are working well, the more superficial ‘helper muscles’ will be able to back off, reducing that feeling of overwhelming tightness or gripping.
We often start with low-load exercises to "wake up" the deep stabilizing muscles before integrating them into larger movements. At PhysioTec, we use Real-Time Ultrasound to visualize these muscles. It allows you to see the mismatch between your gripping superficial muscles and your sometimes sluggish deep stabilizers (especially if you are experiencing pain), providing powerful biofeedback.
3. Isometric Holds: Giving your Joints a Hug
Isometrics, or exercises involving holding a position without moving, are very valuable for those with hypermobility. They can provide several benefits:
- Pain Relief: Sustained isometric holds of 30 to 45 seconds have been shown to reduce pain signals in the brain through cortical inhibition.
- Mapping: They flood the brain with sensory data, helping to clear the "sensorimotor blur" and reduce the need for guarding.
- Coordination: They can assist with improving muscle coordination, important for joint protection, efficient muscle usage and optimal movement patterns.
Performing gentle isometrics, focusing on the deep stabilizers, is like giving your joints a hug!
4. Eccentric Strengthening: Active Lengthening
Where there is true restriction of range of motion, we use eccentric strengthening rather than passive stretching. Eccentric strengthening involves strengthening a muscle while it lengthens. For "tight" hamstrings, exercises like Romanian Deadlifts (RDLs)/ controlled hip hinge actions or eccentric slides teach the muscle (and the nervous system) to control its length.
Eccentric strengthening can create structural lengthening in the muscle’s building blocks (sarcomeres), while only moving in a safe, controlled range. This can assist in allowing you to keep your flexibility but with better muscle control through your range.
Final Thoughts
Your stiffness is a protective splint, not a lack of flexibility.
A focus on stability rather than stretching will provide much better long-term gains.
Your feeling of stiffness is a call for help from the nervous system, when it detects difficulty in efficient control of a mobile system. Your brain deploys a functional splint to protect your joints. Improving local muscle control around your joints and eccentric strength allows you to access your full range safely, reducing pain, stiffness and fatigue while caring for your underlying joints.
Book Your Assessment
Are you tired of feeling tight despite stretching every day? A thorough assessment can help differentiate between true stiffness and protective guarding. At PhysioTec, we can use Real-Time Ultrasound and specific stability testing to map your anatomy and build a plan that works with your hypermobility, not against it. Book an assessment with our Hypermobility team today.
Feeling “tight” all the time, even though you’re naturally flexible?
Book an assessment at PhysioTec and we’ll assess your movement, explain what’s driving your protective tension, and create a personalised plan to help you move with control and confidence!
↓ MAKE A BOOKING TODAY ↓
Author
This blog has been written by one of our experienced PhysioTec physiotherapists. If you would like to book with one of our physio's, call 3342 4284 or click here to book online.
Other great Blogs
AWESOME BLOGS THAT OUR PHYSIO TEAM HAS CONTRIBUTED TO PROUDLY!
Hypermobility: Separating Myths From the Evidence
Bendy joints, aching muscles, and a lifetime of being told “you’re just double-jointed” – sound familiar? Hypermobility is often dismissed…
Medial Elbow Tendinopathy (Golfers Elbow)
Medial elbow tendinopathy (commonly referred to as “Golfer’s elbow”) refers to pain on the inside of your elbow. Often, people…
Posterior Ankle Impingement in Dancers
Ankle pain can be a challenging thing for ballet dancers to overcome. It might creep in during rehearsal, flare up…
PhysioTec is Moving to Salisbury: New Brisbane Physiotherapy location
Same Team. Same Care. New Location. Join us at our new location in Salisbury! Same Trusted Team Same physios, same…
Ischiofemoral Impingement: Symptoms, Diagnosis, Treatment
Hip pain can be a challenging thing to overcome. It might creep in during a run, flare up after a…
Getting More From Your Hip Replacement: Troubleshooting Common Problems after 12 Months
Taking the plunge into hip replacement surgery is a big step, and usually only undertaken after years of hip pain…
The Paradox of “Stiffness” in Hypermobility: Why You Feel Tight (And Why Stretching Isn’t Working)
We all face physical challenges at some point in our lives, but those with hypermobile joints encounter a particularly confusing…
Cycling and Hip Pain – How a Physio Bike Fit Can Help
How lucky are we in South East Queensland to have such a wonderful cycling environment. Cruising along the Brisbane River,…
Acute Back Spasm: A Physiotherapist’s Guide to Recovery
Have you suddenly bent over or got out of bed and felt your lower back seize up? That painful “locked-up”…
Sacroiliac joint pain: Symptoms, Causes, Treatment
Have you developed pain at the base of your spine? Is it on one side? Have you suddenly noticed it’s…
References
- Akaras, E., Deniz, G., Eymir, M., & Sönmez, M. (2025). The effects of joint hypermobility on strength, proprioception, and functional performance. Scientific Reports, 15, 40529. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-24199-x
- Castori, M., Tinkle, B., Levy, H., Grahame, R., Malfait, F., & Hakim, A. (2017). A framework for the classification of joint hypermobility and related conditions. American Journal of Medical Genetics Part C: Seminars in Medical Genetics, 175(1), 148–157. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajmg.c.31539
- Rombaut, L., Malfait, F., De Wandele, I., Mahieu, N., Thijs, Y., Segers, P., & Calders, P. (2012). Muscle-tendon tissue properties in the hypermobility type of Ehlers–Danlos syndrome. Arthritis Care & Research, 64(5), 766–772. https://doi.org/10.1002/acr.21592
- Scheper, M. C., de Vries, J. E., Verbunt, J., & Engelbert, R. H. H. (2017). Chronic pain in hypermobility syndrome and hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome: It is a challenge. Journal of Pain Research, 10, 591–601. https://doi.org/10.2147/JPR.S113984
- AlMohiza, M. A., & Reddy, R. S. (2025). Exploring the dynamics of stability and lumbar proprioception in hypermobility syndrome: A comparative and mediation analysis. Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research, 20, 285. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13018-025-05683-6
- Bonello, C., Girdwood, M., De Souza, K., & Malliaras, P. (2021). Does isometric exercise result in exercise-induced hypoalgesia in individuals with musculoskeletal pain? A systematic review. Physical Therapy in Sport, 49, 51–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ptsp.2021.02.002
- Douglas, J., Pearson, S., Ross, A., & McGuigan, M. (2017). Eccentric exercise: Physiological characteristics and acute responses. Journal of Applied Physiology, 123(3), 534–545. https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00165.2017
- Franchi, M. V., Reeves, N. D., & Narici, M. V. (2017). Skeletal muscle remodeling in response to eccentric vs. concentric loading: Morphological, molecular, and metabolic adaptations. Frontiers in Physiology, 8, 447. https://doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2017.00447
- Hall, M. G., Ferrell, W. R., Sturrock, R. D., Hamblen, D. L., & Baxendale, R. H. (1995). The effect of the hypermobility syndrome on knee joint proprioception. British Journal of Rheumatology, 34(2), 121–125. https://doi.org/10.1093/rheumatology/34.2.121